Monday, February 12, 2018

Hail, Holy Queen by Scott Hahn

This is my last book I have planned to read of the Hahn books.  I'm glad I save this one for last.

When I was in elementary school, I remember in 3rd or 4th grade Sunday school we were talking of different things and I had questions about Mary.  Want to know how to annoy and frustrate an older, Baptist, elementary school Sunday school teacher?  Give her a kid that asks questions about Mary.

I was hoping this book would answer many of my questions I had from over 2 decades ago about Mary.  It did a good job.  A sampling of the questions would be (not all of these from elementary school, some came later):

  • Is Mary God's mother, too? (yes)
  • Do Catholics worship Mary? (no)
  • Did Jesus have brothers? (turns out, not in the sense we use the word)
  • Why does Mary being a perpetual virgin even matter? (turns out it does, read the book, I can't summarize this)
  • Mary is not God, so why do we need to make a big deal about her? (she's our mother)


Ultimately, I gained a much better understanding of both Mary and Marian doctrine.  It was very interesting.  In the end, I could summarize it by saying the following:

If Jesus and God are one person, then Mary is both of their mothers.  God commanded us to honor our mother.  By God being our Father, then that would automatically make Mary our mother.  So, we should honor her.

I'm ok with that.

Really, it was an extremely interesting book that shows how Mary is the New Eve, as well as how and why she should be honored (not worshiped).  As I have thought with all of Hahn's books, if you are a Protestant and want to better under Catholicism, you should read it.  (Ditto for Catholics who want to better understand Mary.

175 pages

Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Hidden by Catherine McKenzie

I've had this book on my Kindle for almost 4 years.  I just hadn't read it, but it's on my TBR list on Goodreads.  I get an email probably once a month about a "giveaway" for this book.

I read it because I wanted to mark it read and get rid of the stupid "giveaway" emails.

I thought the fact that it was being given away so often meant one of two things:
- It's a great book, and the author tries to give back by giving away books
- It's a terrible book, and the author tries to earn readers by giving away books

I think it's the latter.  The book is about Jeff, who dies early in the book.  He leaves behind his wife Claire and his coworker/secret love/friend/whatever Tish.  Tish goes to the funeral.  Claire gets suspicions.  The book was written with Claire, Tish, and Jeff narrating.  It got confusing to keep straight who was who.  You eventually knew, but overall it was frustrating.

The characters themselves were pretty superficial.  They weren't all that well-developed.  We got a lot of what in the story, but not a lot of why or how.  I found them simultaneously annoying and interesting, but not a great interesting.  There were so many weird connections, too.  Claire used to date Jeff's brother Tim.  Seth, Claire and Jeff's son read a poem from Zoey's (Tish and Brian's daughter) book at his Dad's funeral.  The connections were supposed to make the story complex but just muddled it.

The story pretty much played out how I thought it would and the epilogue didn't surprise me at all.  Overall, a decent read for a blah day, but not what I expected.

305 pages

Wednesday, January 24, 2018

The Four Loves by C.S. Lewis

I really enjoy C.S. Lewis.  I haven't read many of his books (and ironically only have read his non-fiction stuff), but I love his quotes and thoughts.  I read A Grief Observed towards the end of last year.

The Four Loves was an interesting book.  Lewis broke down the human/Godly notion/emotion of love into various parts.  I'm going to try my best to summarize them, but Lewis I am not, so to get the fullness of the book, you'll want to read it.

There are three "categories" of love that exist to make up the four loves.  They are as follows, and may exist independently but usually exist in combination with one another:

  • Need-love: Exists because of the need to love and be loved.  This can be a selfish love, but not totally selfish as we need love just as we need food.  However, it may disappear once the need for it is satisfied.
  • Gift-love: This love exists to be totally selfless. It is the type of love that is given without anything expected in return. 
  • Appreciative-love: This love exists because of the appreciation of something.  It happens when the giver deems that the receiver is worthy of love.  
Next a quick summary of the four loves:
  • Affection: This is the type of love that happens between parents and children, people who have grown accustom to being around each other (roommates, coworkers, etc).  It's the type of love you have for people you are comfortable around (in a sense).  However, a downfall to this type of love is that it can cause you to get too comfortable and lack common courtesy.  Jealousy can stem from this type of love as well.
  • Friendship: This type of love is both the least common and least natural.  He states it is actually the greatest of the non-Godly loves. It does not have jealousy because sharing with more friends tends to improve the friendship.  It's also a totally unnecessary love, but one that improves our survival (we don't need friendship to survive, but it does provide value to the survival).  What was particularly interesting to me was the distinction he pointed out between companionship and true friendship.  He also said it is spiritual but not holy and that it is "the instrument by which God reveals to each the beauties of all the others".
  • Eros: This type of love is often spoke of negatively by Christians.  It is romantic love which may or may not be sexual in nature.  Lust vs eros is discussed here as well (from a man's perspective because Lewis is male: lust is the pleasure a man can derive from a woman, the woman is simply the way the pleasure is delivered; eros is the desire for the woman herself regardless as to if he could derive pleasure from her or pleasure compared to other women).  He mentions that a man would stay with a woman he loved but knew would not make him happy because he thinks it would be better to be unhappy with her than happy without her.  
  • Charity: This type of love is the love that God bestows upon us.  While he does not ever use the term "Agape" that is what he is meaning here.  He states that this type of love is what allows people to give their lives to God.  He goes into more detail here, but not in a way that is easily summarized.  Essentially it's loving the unlovable.  

Lewis also says that each type of love is like a garden, unless it is tended to and not just planted, then the love cannot stay good and will turn bad.  He also went on to talk about how each of the loves is trying to prepare us to love God, because we can't fully grasp how we will love Him.  There was a section in there about if we will still feel the same about our Beloveds in Heaven and it was pretty interesting as well.  (Depends on how you loved them, essentially.)

A sampling of my favorite quotes from this book to leave you with (there's a lot, I really like C.S. Lewis, especially the stuff on Friendship):

Need love says of a woman "I cannot live without her"; Gift-love longs to give her happiness, comfort, protection - if possible, wealth; Appreciative love gazes and holds its breath and is silent, rejoices that such a wonder should exist even if not for him, will not be wholly dejected by losing her, would rather have it so than never to have seen her at all." 

Nor do I question for a moment that Affection is responsible for nine-tenths of whatever solid and durable happiness there is in our natural lives.

But very few modern people think Friendship a love of comparable value or even a love at all.

But in Friendship - in that luminous, tranquil, rational world of relationships freely chosen - you got away from all that.  This alone, of all the loves, seemed to raise you to the level of gods or angels.

When the two people who thus discover that they are on the same secret road are of different sexes, the friendship which arises between them will very easily pass - may pass in the first half-hour - into erotic love.  Indeed, unless they are physically repulsive to each other or unless one or both of already loves elsewhere, it is almost certain to do so sooner or later. (Apparently Lewis buys into the "When Harry Met Sally" theory that men and women can never be "just friends")

Eros will have naked bodies; Friendship will have naked personalities.

Friday, January 12, 2018

Space at the Table by Brad and Drew Harper

I listened to this book on Audible and I'm glad I listened to it instead of reading it.  It's read by the authors, and sometimes that can be a bad thing but I think this time it was perfect.

Drew is gay.  His dad, Brad, is an evangelical theologian.  This book is their memoir as to how they grew apart and then came to terms with each other.  There was painful parts to listen to.  There were incredible parts to listen to as well.  

My brother-in-law happens to be gay.  I was the first person he came out to because he said he knew it wouldn't change who he was to me.  And it didn't.  I love him...regardless of who he loves.  I will forever be his staunchest supporter.  That being said, there are some things with my faith that I struggle with reconciling.  Just a little though, because the most important thing in my faith, to me, is LOVE, so that makes it easier.  

There were some places in the book that pointed out how a person can say something seemingly harmless but that is in actuality harmful.  

There were parts of the book that moved slower than I wanted or repeated itself, but overall I loved it.  If you claim to be a Christian and want to understand homosexuality and how to better love, read this book.  Better yet, listen to it.

224 pages/5hr 45min

Wednesday, January 3, 2018

The Art of Loving by Erich Fromm

The Art of Loving by Erich Fromm was written in 1956, so it just recently had it's 60th birthday.  It is still incredibly relevant today.  It could have been written yesterday.  It was really good, so this is going to be a bit of a spastic, all over the place, review....

In this book, which isn't a self-help or relationship book so much as it is a book about self-love, Fromm talks about how culture has gotten love all wrong.  Keeping in mind that this is a 60 year old book, I'd submit that we have taken it even further than that at this point.  He maintains that love isn't something that happens (such as "falling in love") but an action that one does.  It's an activity, an art, something that must be learned and practiced.  

The book beings:
Is love an art? Then it requires knowledge and effort. Or is love a pleasant sensation, which to experience is a matter of chance, something one “falls into” if one is lucky? This little book is based on the former premise, while undoubtedly the majority of people today believe it is the latter.

He believes that a major problem of love is that people think about love in the terms of being loved instead of giving love. We strive to adjust who we are in order to become more loved.  This is a fruitless effort, especially if the person is a lonely person.  We think of love as about loving something and not about how to love, how to learn the art of loving.  We also don't distinguish between "falling in love" and "standing in love".  He says that two former strangers meeting and connecting is one of the most exhilarating experiences a person can have.  He states that this is not lasting though because eventually they will become well acquainted and become bored with each other and lose the magical qualities of infatuation.  That this does not prove love, but only proves the degree of their preceding loneliness.  It is in this boredom that one must choose to love and not desire to be loved. 

He spoke of the four main aspects of true love: care, responsibility, respect, and knowledge.  He talked about how a person has to care for themselves, take responsibility, respect themselves, and know themselves (which includes owning ones weaknesses AND strengths).  A person can't truly love another unless they can fully love themselves.  He writes of brotherly love (the noblest of all loves which must underlie all the others, he claims), motherly and fatherly love (including interesting references to religious denominations), erotic love, self love, and the love of God.

I think the most interesting chapter for me was about the disintegration of love in the Western culture.  We basically killed love.  It was very interesting.  The last chapter is a not-how-to-guide-how-to-guide.  Fromm describes it as this:  "...many readers of this book, expect to be given prescriptions of "how to do it yourself," and that means in our case to be taught how to love.  I am afraid that anyone who approaches this let chapter in this spirit will be gravely disappointed."  This last chapter was very good, but a little scattered.

There was so much good in this book.  I highlighted over 80 passages in a 105 page book.  I'll leave you with some that stuck out to me (there could be a lot more, I even had to pair this down):

If I am like everybody else, if I have no feelings or thoughts which make me different, if I conform in custom, dress, ideas, to the pattern of the group, I am saved; saved from the frightening experience of aloneness.

Love is an activity, not a passive affect; it is a “standing in,” not a “falling for.” In the most general way, the active character of love can be described by stating that love is primarily giving, not receiving.

If I love the other person, I feel one with him or her, but with him as he is, not as I need him to be as an object for my use.

I may know, for instance, that a person is angry, even if he does not show it overtly; but I may know him more deeply than that; then I know that he is anxious, and worried; that he feels lonely, that he feels guilty. Then I know that his anger is only the manifestation of something deeper, and I see him as anxious and embarrassed, that is, as the suffering person, rather than as the angry one.

All this kind of relationship amounts to is the well‑oiled relationship between two persons who remain strangers all their lives, who never arrive at a “central relationship,” but who treat each other with courtesy and who attempt to make each other feel better.

Love is possible only if two persons communicate with each other from the center of their existence, hence if each one of them experiences himself from the center of his existence. Only in this “central experience” is human reality, only here is aliveness, only here is the basis for love. Love, experienced thus, is a constant challenge; it is not a resting place, but a moving, growing, working together; even whether there is harmony or conflict, joy or sadness, is secondary to the fundamental fact that two people experience themselves from the essence of their existence, that they are one with each other by being one with themselves, rather than by fleeing from themselves. There is only one proof for the presence of love: the depth of the relationship, and the aliveness and strength in each person concerned; this is the fruit by which love is recognized.

105 pages


Friday, December 29, 2017

The Lamb's Supper by Scott Hahn

The church I attend has been going through the Book of Revelation.  When I was reading Reasons to Believe (same author) I noticed that he had a book on the Book of Revelation as well.  His take was slightly different than that of my church/preacher.  It was extraordinarily interesting, and I will readily admit, made much more sense than any other view of Revelation I've heard.

He takes the sacrifices of the Old Testament and connects them with the death of Jesus at Calvary.  (Old Testaments sacrifices were often livestock - lambs, for instance, and Jesus is the Lamb who was the ultimate sacrifice.)  He also talks about the writings of the early Christians.  He discusses how Catholic Mass was conducted in the early, early church...which is remarkably consistent to my understanding of how it is conducted today.  There was a page that I found particularly interesting that showed the parts of Mass and the text in Rev that correlated to it.

What intrigued me the most though was the symbols in Rev.  Many, many preachers interpret them in an apocalyptic sense.  Hahn went through them in a liturgical sense - showing how they are really just symbols of the Mass.  When Heaven touches down to the New Jerusalem, which is Mount Zion, the Church of the Upper Room, he says that it is Mass.  So...essentially in Mass, some of Heaven comes down to the earth.  Which makes perfect sense given some of the occurrences in Mass (transubstantiation) wouldn't be able to happen without some Heavenly intervention. 


It also discusses how God in three persons is a family.  Pope John Paul II is quoted in the book as saying, "God in His deepest mystery is not a solitude, but a family, since he has in Himself fatherhood, sonship, and the essence of the family, which is love." 


The church I attend wraps up the series on Revelation this week.  I'm particularly curious to see how it is concluded.  I cannot say for sure, and probably shouldn't even write this as an attender of a non-denominational church, but I have a deep feeling it will make much less sense than the Hahn (Catholic) interpretation of Revelation.

I got a library card at the library near my work and picked up "Hail, Holy Queen" also by Hahn.  I'm going to read it soon and hopefully have many of my Mary questions answered.  I'm looking forward to it.

163 pages

Saturday, December 23, 2017

Brave by Tammara Webber

Yet another book I thought I’d read a chapter of after I got it on an Amazon special and it sucked me in.

Erin is the daughter of wealthy parents who is dealing with tr fallout in her personal life from a pretty traumatic event. She was planning to go to grad school, but instead is the new “client liaison” (newly created position) for her dad’s company. Her new boss is none too pleased that he gets to supervise the boss’ daughter.

Isaac is a well-educated guy who is not really wanting to supervise the boss’ daughter. He’s there for other reasons and babysitting isn’t one of them. He also doesn’t think the spoiled little rich girl can take care of the whining, spoiled clients that aren’t happy.

Imagine both of their surprise when she not only does the job, but is awesome at the job. Imagine even bigger surprises when Erin is falling for her boss.

There’s just one problem. Isaac has other motivations for being there. Erin is off-limits because of her  racist grandparents that Isaac has a bone to pick with from something that happened before he was born. (Isaac is black, Erin is white)

Isaac makes some startling discoveries, there’s a big family blowup, and a few twists here and there. Overall it was a quick and easy, if mostly predictable, read. It did have a happily ever after ending, which was nice.

300 pages (and it completes my 15 book goal for 2017!)

Monday, December 18, 2017

An Abundance of Katherines by John Green

I loved TFiOS.  This was another John Green novel AND its basis was figuring out a math equation.  The math equation was supposed to predict the demise of a relationship and who the dumper and dumpee was going to be.

The main character, Colin, is devastated because his girlfriend just dumped him.  His 19th girlfriend...all of whom were named Katherine.  He's a super smart kid, a prodigy, and has lots of talents.  Getting over Katherine the Nineteenth is not one of those talents, so he and his friend set out on a road trip, end up in Gutshot, TN and find work and pseudo-adventure.

I really REALLY wanted to like this book.  But I didn't.  The characters were pretty shallow and whiny, there was cutesy language in there that was supposed to take place of cursing (fug? fugger?  really?), and it just was not what I expected.  It felt like an overdone high school writing assignment.  I still really like John Green, but this book was disappointing.  It had potential, but I think he must have been hurried in writing it or something.  Because...wow.

But, it wasn't horrible, and was a fast listen, so I can't complain.  I listened to the audiobook and the narrator was great, but the Stephen Hawking-like computer voice for any character on the phone was annoying.  I'd give it a solid 3 stars, but no more than that.

6hrs 48min/229 pages

Thursday, December 14, 2017

The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas

Starr, who is black (it's important), has had a mixed bag of life experiences.  She has now watched two of her best friends be gunned down and killed in the "ghetto" where she lives.  (Note: she goes to school at an affluent school an hour away because her parents don't want her in Garden Heights.)  Once when she was younger and again later in life when her best friend Khalil was shot and kill by "115" - a white police officer.  She was in the car and had the gun pointed on her after Khalil lay dead in the street.  This book is her story.  It's about how the people in her neighborhood just want to be seen as equals to everyone else.  Which, honestly, isn't much to ask but seems to be asking for the world.  Star has to face a grand jury, riots, her dad's wrath about her white boyfriend, and gang leaders/drug dealers. She also wants to give Khalil a face of who he was and not what the media shows.  Her brothers, sort-of sister, and parents, plus others in the neighborhood, are pulled into all of it with her.

She wants people to know that "he lived" and because of this his death, and he, matters.

As it turns out, my skin lacks eumelanin.  What does that mean?  Well, it means I'm WHITE.  It also means I've been bestowed certain privileges in life that people with more eumelanin (read: darker skin) have not.  What are some of these?  I've never had a conversation with my parents about the way to behave appropriately around law enforcement.  I've never had someone expect certain (negative) behavior from me simply because of my skin pigmentation.  I've never had someone cross on the other side of the street simply because they don't want to be near me.

Make you uncomfortable for me to say that?  Well, then I'd say you need to read this book.  I, in my (thankfully pretty distant) past acted in ways that I know now was at best marginally racist and at worst flat out racist.  Life experience has changed me and I have become a much more understanding, open-minded, not racist person who just loves.  (Or at least I’m pretty sure I have.) But, reading this book gave me a bigger glimpse into the stories we hear.  The other side of the story that isn't portrayed.  AND IT IS SUPER IMPORTANT TO HEAR.  If people can't listen and understand each other, how will we ever get past this insanity all because we look a little different than our neighbor?

There are also some amazing quotes in this book, too.  Here are some favorites:

“At an early age I learned that people make mistakes, and you have to decide if their mistakes are bigger than your love for them.” 

“I can't change where I come from or what I've been through, so why should I be ashamed of what makes me, me?” 

“Once you've seen how broken someone is it's like seeing them naked—you can't look at them the same anymore.” 

Seriously, the more you think you don't want to read this book, the more you need to sit down, open your mind, and read this book.  I listened to the Audible version and the narrator was amazing.  It's going to be a movie.  I want to go see it.


464 pages/11h40m

Friday, December 1, 2017

Reasons to Believe by Scott Hahn

I picked up Reasons as part of my continued Reformation reading.  It was an extremely interesting look at the Catholic faith, including the why and how the beliefs of the Church.  They were divided into three distinct sections: Natural Reasons, Biblical Reasons, Royal Reasons.  I particularly appreciated that Hahn broke the sections out this way, because it was a very logical way to explain the Church.

Since I was small I had questions regarding Mary, salvation, and many other things.  I was raised Protestant, but this look inside the Catholic faith has shown me many things, the main two being:
1. Protestants and Catholics aren't really ALL that far apart.
2. There are exceptionally valid reasons for the differences in beliefs by Catholics and Protestants.

A wonderful friend is Catholic and we've had some great conversations about (loosely) the information in the book (and more broadly, many other things).  I've really loved having someone that I can ask questions to without feeling like I'm being preached to or being stupid or being judged.  This book has prompted more conversations.

The entire concept of Mass intrigues me, as I've only been to a couple of Catholic Masses.  The third and final book I'm planning to read by Hahn.  (Though he has one on Mary, too, and I might read that one as well.)  Reading about the Catholic faith through the eyes of a former Protestant is rather cool and I'm enjoying it immensely.

227 pages