Monday, February 12, 2018

Hail, Holy Queen by Scott Hahn

This is my last book I have planned to read of the Hahn books.  I'm glad I save this one for last.

When I was in elementary school, I remember in 3rd or 4th grade Sunday school we were talking of different things and I had questions about Mary.  Want to know how to annoy and frustrate an older, Baptist, elementary school Sunday school teacher?  Give her a kid that asks questions about Mary.

I was hoping this book would answer many of my questions I had from over 2 decades ago about Mary.  It did a good job.  A sampling of the questions would be (not all of these from elementary school, some came later):

  • Is Mary God's mother, too? (yes)
  • Do Catholics worship Mary? (no)
  • Did Jesus have brothers? (turns out, not in the sense we use the word)
  • Why does Mary being a perpetual virgin even matter? (turns out it does, read the book, I can't summarize this)
  • Mary is not God, so why do we need to make a big deal about her? (she's our mother)


Ultimately, I gained a much better understanding of both Mary and Marian doctrine.  It was very interesting.  In the end, I could summarize it by saying the following:

If Jesus and God are one person, then Mary is both of their mothers.  God commanded us to honor our mother.  By God being our Father, then that would automatically make Mary our mother.  So, we should honor her.

I'm ok with that.

Really, it was an extremely interesting book that shows how Mary is the New Eve, as well as how and why she should be honored (not worshiped).  As I have thought with all of Hahn's books, if you are a Protestant and want to better under Catholicism, you should read it.  (Ditto for Catholics who want to better understand Mary.

175 pages

Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Hidden by Catherine McKenzie

I've had this book on my Kindle for almost 4 years.  I just hadn't read it, but it's on my TBR list on Goodreads.  I get an email probably once a month about a "giveaway" for this book.

I read it because I wanted to mark it read and get rid of the stupid "giveaway" emails.

I thought the fact that it was being given away so often meant one of two things:
- It's a great book, and the author tries to give back by giving away books
- It's a terrible book, and the author tries to earn readers by giving away books

I think it's the latter.  The book is about Jeff, who dies early in the book.  He leaves behind his wife Claire and his coworker/secret love/friend/whatever Tish.  Tish goes to the funeral.  Claire gets suspicions.  The book was written with Claire, Tish, and Jeff narrating.  It got confusing to keep straight who was who.  You eventually knew, but overall it was frustrating.

The characters themselves were pretty superficial.  They weren't all that well-developed.  We got a lot of what in the story, but not a lot of why or how.  I found them simultaneously annoying and interesting, but not a great interesting.  There were so many weird connections, too.  Claire used to date Jeff's brother Tim.  Seth, Claire and Jeff's son read a poem from Zoey's (Tish and Brian's daughter) book at his Dad's funeral.  The connections were supposed to make the story complex but just muddled it.

The story pretty much played out how I thought it would and the epilogue didn't surprise me at all.  Overall, a decent read for a blah day, but not what I expected.

305 pages